Thanks for the replies. Took tension off belts, and there was a wobble in the pulley. As sidekick suggested, the bearings inside the four-groove sheave were spinning inside the sheave, rather than the bearing itself turning. What would cause that to happenIJ At any rate, new sheave not available from AGCO; we'll probably get a used one from either Abilene Machine or Worthington Ag Parts (waiting to hear back on prices). Thanks again for the help.